Print the page
Increase font size
Everyone Loves the Rally…. Except the Data

Posted October 13, 2025

Enrique Abeyta

By Enrique Abeyta

Everyone Loves the Rally…. Except the Data

As you’ve heard by now, Trump threatened to slap massive tariffs on China late last week.

The U.S. stock market dropped immediately after Trump’s post and continued to fall throughout the afternoon.

Friday ended up being the single largest one-day decline since the selloff in April after the"Liberation Day" tariffs.

What made the drop even more surprising was how strong the market had been up until then, notching new highs without looking back.

Stocks rebounded today after Trump downplayed the tension and said it “will all be fine!”

Now, I ordinarily advise that you tune out this kind of noise. But it brings up an important question.

If one social media post can send this bull market reeling, is it really that strong after all? The data says maybe not.

Early Warning Signs Are Flashing

Stocks have been on a hot streak for the past few months. But when you look at the data, a few key indicators are starting to show cracks in the foundation.

The McClellan Summation Index, a widely followed measure of breadth, has flattened and drifted lower over recent weeks, even as the major indices made new highs.

That divergence often indicates that fewer stocks are doing the heavy lifting.

Breadth data from the NYSE paints a similar picture.

Out of roughly 3,000 listed stocks, only two of the past 10 sessions have seen more than a thousand names making new highs, a surprisingly weak showing during a record-setting run.

Over that period, breadth was positive on just five days and negative on five, indicating that participation has narrowed considerably.

Perhaps one of the clearest warning signs has been the underperformance of quality stocks.

Below is a chart that compares the S&P Quality ETF to the broader S&P 500, showing a sharp decline over the past month.

This suggests that investors have shifted away from companies with strong fundamentals and into more speculative corners of the market.

Small-cap data underscores this shift.

According to Bloomberg data, only 57% of Russell 2000 companies are currently profitable, while 41% are not.

Since April’s lows, the profitable group has gained 22%, while the unprofitable stocks have surged 53%.

That imbalance is not the hallmark of a fundamentally driven rally.

Money has rotated between groups — restaurants, asset managers, homebuilders, and then back into mega-caps.

This activity is keeping the major averages afloat, but the narrowing leadership and speculative rotation typically don’t last forever.

The rally's foundation remains shaky without broader participation and renewed strength from quality names.

And as the rotation goes on, retail and professional investors alike plow money into increasingly speculative stocks, while precious metals and crypto are also trading near all-time highs.

If you were to take 10 minutes to scroll through investing-related feeds on X, you would observe signs of market euphoria.

Online chatter around the Mag 7 and other companies with strong fundamentals is drowned out by speculative AI trades and astronomical gains from stocks you've never heard of.

What Does It All Mean?

On the surface, the market still looks healthy. However, the underlying structure is weakening.

Breadth is narrowing, quality is lagging, sentiment is overheated, and speculative behavior is rising.

While none of this promises a major pullback tomorrow, it does suggest that the rally everyone loves is increasingly out of step with the data.

I’m not raising a red flag yet. But staying disciplined and watching these indicators closely may prove crucial in the weeks ahead.

Because, in the end, it's not about how much money you make, it's how much you keep.

The Leverage Trap: A Painful Lesson in Risk

The Leverage Trap: A Painful Lesson in Risk

Posted October 17, 2025

By Greg Guenthner

Even in a rip-roaring bull market like the one we’re in now, you have to know how to protect yourself.
4 Hard Truths for a Parabolic Market

4 Hard Truths for a Parabolic Market

Posted October 16, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

The market has felt unstoppable lately, but it won’t last forever. In fact, it could come to an end at any moment.
How to Handle a Bubble — You Have Four Options

How to Handle a Bubble — You Have Four Options

Posted October 09, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

You don’t have to be a market expert to spot a bubble. The hard part is knowing what to do about it.
5 Charts Prove This Bull Has Legs

5 Charts Prove This Bull Has Legs

Posted October 06, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

All signs indicate that the market could end 2025 with a bang.
The “Forgotten Stepchild” Precious Metal Is Waking Up

The “Forgotten Stepchild” Precious Metal Is Waking Up

Posted October 05, 2025

By Ian Culley

Gold hit record highs. Silver is surging. Now palladium, the last holdout in the precious metals rally, is ready to break out.
The Premier Anomaly: Why Momentum Trading Has Captivated Wall Street for 30 Years

The Premier Anomaly: Why Momentum Trading Has Captivated Wall Street for 30 Years

Posted October 03, 2025

By Greg Guenthner

Winning stocks tend to keep winning, and losing stocks tend to keep losing. This shouldn’t happen in an efficient market… but it does.